Dispensary Bought or Homemade Edibles? Which Is Better?

Making marijuana or psilocybin gummies at home versus buying them from a dispensary offers a variety of pros and cons, each with its own set of considerations. Psilocybin, known for its therapeutic potential, is being explored in edibles like chocolates, teas, and gummies.

This growing trend shows an increasing interest in personalized, alternative methods of consumption for both recreational and medical purposes. It parallels the path previously treaded by cannabis, with magic mushrooms now being integrated into a variety of edible forms.

There are even ready-to-go gummy kits and instructions, such as Maestrodose's recipe for mushroom gummies. These forms are not only more appetizing but also easier for beginners, addressing issues like the unpalatable taste and texture of raw mushrooms​​.

In this article, we will talk a little more about marijuana edibles, the pros and cons of making them yourself, and compare dispensary-bought alternatives to homemade ones. Let’s get started!

About Cannabis Edibles

Cannabis edibles have gained popularity because of their versatility and the ability to infuse a wide range of ingredients with THC and CBD.

Homemade alternatives offer the freedom to choose from a range of recipes, from the classic pot brownie to more sophisticated culinary creations, using base ingredients like cannabutter, cannabis oil, and even honey that contains marijuana​​.

Although cannabis and psilocybin are fundamentally different, the interest in creating edibles at home reflects a broader desire for a more personalized and potentially therapeutic experience.

The process of making these edibles at home varies in complexity. It typically requires more steps, involving the decarboxylation of the flower and infusion into fats like butter or oil. On the other hand, psilocybin edibles are somewhat simpler to make, as they don’t require fat molecules for the extraction of psychoactive compounds​​.

Advantages of Making Edibles at Home

There are many benefits to making edibles from home. It can be a fun process while saving money and time by preventing the need to have to stand in line at the dispensary. Below are some of the benefits of making your own edibles versus going to the store to buy them.


  • Control Over Ingredients: When you make your own edibles, you have complete control over the quality and source of the ingredients. This is particularly advantageous for people with specific dietary preferences or restrictions, such as vegan or organic diets​​​​.
  • Cost-Effectiveness: Making edibles at home can be more economical in the long run, especially if you are a frequent consumer. The initial investment in ingredients and equipment is often offset by the savings from not purchasing pre-made products​​​​.
  • Customization of Potency and Flavor: When you make gummies at home, you have complete control over the strength and taste. You can adjust the amount of cannabis-infused oil or butter to suit your desired potency. Additionally, you can experiment with different flavors and sweeteners, like honey, maple syrup, or various fruit juices, to tailor the taste to your preference​​​​.
  • Quality Control and Safety: By preparing your own gummies, you can be certain of the ingredients used, ensuring that they are of high quality and safe for consumption. This is especially important for those with dietary restrictions or allergies​​​​.
  • Discretion and Convenience: Homemade gummies offer a discreet and convenient way to consume cannabis or psilocybin, particularly for those who prefer not to smoke or vape. They are easy to store, transport, and consume discreetly​​​​.
  • Fun and Creativity in the Kitchen: Making your own gummies can be a fun and creative process. It’s an opportunity to experiment with different shapes, colors, and flavors, making the experience enjoyable beyond just the consumption of the product​​. It is also an informative experience, providing insight into the properties of cannabis and cooking techniques​​.
  • Storage and Longevity: When stored correctly, homemade gummies can last for several weeks in the refrigerator or even months in the freezer. This is beneficial for those who want to prepare in bulk and use them over time​​.

Drawbacks of Making Edibles at Home

While there are many benefits to homemade edible concoctions, there are also drawbacks. A couple of big reasons some people shy away from making edibles at home include needing help to figure out dosage levels and the fear of ruining the end product and losing out on the investment in supplies. 

Having a good understanding of both the good and the bad can help you make an informed decision on whether to make your edibles yourself. Here are some of the disadvantages of producing your own edibles at home:


  • Dosage Accuracy: One of the biggest challenges is ensuring consistent and accurate dosing. Homemade edibles can vary in potency, which might be problematic, especially for medical marijuana patients who require consistent effects​​​​​​.
  • The Time and Skill Required: The process of making edibles requires time, patience, and a certain level of culinary skill. It can be challenging for beginners or those who are not adept in the kitchen​​​​.
  • Safety and Contamination Risks: Without the controlled environment of a dispensary, there's a higher risk of allergen contamination or unintended substances in your edibles​​.

Advantages of Buying Edibles from a Dispensary

Purchasing edibles from a dispensary comes with its own set of advantages that cater to various consumer needs. One of the primary benefits is the precision of dosage.

The truth is that edibles bought from dispensaries are typically lab-tested, providing accurate and consistent information regarding their THC and CBD content. This aspect is particularly vital for beginners who are new to cannabis consumption and for medical users who rely on specific dosages for therapeutic purposes.

Another significant benefit is the convenience these products offer. Ready-made edibles from dispensaries require no preparation, making them an ideal choice for individuals with busy lifestyles who seek a quick and hassle-free cannabis experience. This ease of use extends to those who may not have the time or inclination to prepare edibles at home.

Additionally, the quality and safety regulations that dispensaries adhere to cannot be overstated. These establishments follow strict guidelines to ensure their products are free from contaminants and meet rigorous health standards.

This regulation provides consumers with the assurance that the edibles they purchase are safe and of high quality, addressing concerns about the potential risks associated with homemade products that are not lab-tested.

Drawbacks of Buying Edibles from a Dispensary

There are several drawbacks to consider when purchasing edibles from a dispensary. One notable concern is the higher cost associated with these products.

The increased price of pre-made edibles is often attributed to the extensive processes they undergo, including production, testing, and compliance with regulatory standards. This additional cost can be a deterrent for some consumers, especially those who use edibles regularly.

Another limitation of dispensary-bought edibles is the variety offered. Although dispensaries typically have a range of edible products available, they may not fully cater to the unique preferences of all consumers. Those seeking specific flavors or ingredients tailored to their tastes or dietary requirements might find the options at dispensaries somewhat restrictive.

Also, the experience of purchasing edibles from a dispensary can sometimes lack a personal touch.

Unlike homemade edibles, where the maker can infuse personal creativity and customization into the process, store-bought edibles don't offer the same level of personal satisfaction and connection that comes from creating a product by yourself.

This aspect might be important for individuals who value the process of making and personalizing their edibles as much as the consumption itself.

A Matter of Personal Preference

Whether making your own edibles or purchasing them from a dispensary is better depends on your personal preferences, needs, and circumstances. Home preparation allows for more control and customization. However, it requires more effort and carries risks in terms of dosing accuracy.

On the other hand, dispensary edibles provide convenience, safety, and precise dosing but may be more costly and less personalized.

The choice ultimately depends on what you value most. You can use the pros and cons of each option listed above to help guide your decision on whether to make your cannabis edibles at home or purchase it from a dispensary.

Leave a comment

All comments are moderated before being published

Our Philosophy

Our bottom-line commitment is to have happy customers.

Rather than focusing on raising margins and obsessing over profits, we've achieved an extraordinary customer retention rate by offering competitive prices, superior products, and – perhaps most importantly – world-class customer service.

Our philosophy will never change: When you're happy, we're happy.